Honest reviews. Smarter beauty buys.

Brand review

Maybelline New York Review

The drugstore makeup giant behind Sky High mascara and Fit Me foundation. Here is what each best seller does well and where it falls short.

Shop Maybelline New York See the best sellers

Products reviewed
1
Origin
1915, United States
Reviewed by
Ashley Carter
Updated
October 14, 2026

Maybelline New York best sellers, reviewed

1 products

Why shoppers pick Maybelline New York

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara product shot
Image: Maybelline New York

Drugstore staple

A L’Oréal-owned brand known for budget makeup.

Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless Foundation product shot
Image: Maybelline New York

Shade matching is the catch

Most foundation complaints are about shade and undertone.

Maybelline Fit Me Dewy + Smooth Foundation product shot
Image: Maybelline New York

Product pages note incentivized reviews

Averages may be inflated.

Maybelline Super Stay Up to 24HR Skin Tint with Vitamin C product shot
Image: Maybelline New York

Dropper and hygiene gripes

The skin tint dropper and concealer applicator get complaints.

Our take on Maybelline New York

Maybelline New York was founded in 1915 and has been owned by L’Oréal since 1996. It is one of the best-known drugstore makeup brands in the US.

We read independent reviews of 5 best sellers, including the complaints, and scored each on a five-point editorial scale. The short version: people like the mascara and Fit Me foundations for the price, and the most common complaints are shade matching, shine control on dry skin and messy applicators.

Watch: the best of Maybelline

This creator picks the best Maybelline products. It is their opinion, not ours.

The Very BEST of MAYBELLINE! · Makeup By Nikki La Rose

What to know before you buy

Many reviews are on retailer sites, and some are incentivized or PR-provided, so we weight complaints and editors’ tests alongside star ratings. Makeup shades vary by market.

This is general information, not medical advice. If you have persistent or severe skin concerns, ask a dermatologist.

Maybelline New York FAQ

Who owns Maybelline?

L’Oréal, which bought the brand in 1996. Maybelline was founded in 1915.

Which Maybelline product is most popular?

Lash Sensational Sky High mascara and the Fit Me foundations have thousands of retailer reviews.

Is Fit Me good for dry skin?

Reviewers say the Matte + Poreless suits oily skin and can cling to dry patches; the Dewy + Smooth suits normal to dry.

Are shade ranges a problem?

Shade matching is the most common complaint across Maybelline foundations.

Are the ratings independent?

Some Maybelline pages note that average ratings include incentivized reviews.

Ready to try Maybelline New York?

Shop the full range on the official site.

Shop Maybelline New York

Affiliate link: we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Why?

Sources: Maybelline on Wikipedia · Sky High mascara review (Really Ree) · Fit Me foundation review (Woman & Home)

Affiliate disclosure: some links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Read our affiliate disclosure.